Finish It!

The shadow of Creetobscare grows long as Ty from Side Character Quest joins us to find out if we could be a deer! What could be spookier?! Three deer? DON’T BE RIDICULOUS! Ty gets stuck in deer Groundhog Day, rutting territory is disputed, and vegetation is munched. Also, Ty brings a homerun D&D style quiz […]

The bells toll thrice for the third week of Creeptobscare! Dani and Bill from Escape this Podcast and Solve This Murder join to battle lizard people on a moving train as grandmas just keep popping up left and right. Also, we receive a visit from a very special surprise caller, brainstorm birthday/halloween synergy, and make […]

On this second week of Creeptobscare, Michael Jonathan Smith from Cobra Kai and the upcoming Twisted Metal TV series joins the spoopy fun! Chris forces him to answer the age old question, how do you boo? Also, Chris challenges Michael to a round of Scary Movie Synonyms, and a bunch of crazy kitty cats cause […]

Creeptobscare begins! This week, Chris escapes the cruel yoke of Matt’s talent and takes the incredible Stephen C. James for a bumpy journey through a very very bad first day of school. Also, Chris challenges Stephen to a round of Are you a Wimp or Do You Laugh at Fear?” and they uncover the dirty […]

This week, Chris' adventure is violent yellow! Matt's is long brown! Why all the obfuscation? Because surprises! It's a real long one but it's a real epic adventure! With only two endings left, will they finish this book? YOU WILL NOT BELIEVE IT.

In this week's episode, Chris finds Luigi doing math badly, and Matt develops a whole theory of choice-making based on solving puzzles and playing it smart and this freakin' book slaps him back down hard. Who does he think he is?!

In this week's epic episode, Chris accomplishes his mission but instantly regrets it, Matt swings big and HITS and also MISSES, and it's a triple segment bonus blast!

This week, Matt gets muffled by ectoplasm, Chris discovers a whole new color, and Luigi full on loses it while blasting monsters after his precious moustache is singed!

This week, Chris uncovers a mysterious body hair grooming situation, Matt runs blindly into the darkness, and there are loops! Loops and loops and loops! Loops within loops! It is a nightmare!

This week, Matt learns that Koopa cakes exist and are horrible, Chris comes across the most incomprehensible puzzle yet, and one brother gets what could be the darkest ending in the book!

This week, Chris learns some shocking Koopa lore, Matt learns the Brooklyn Plumbers' War Cry, and Luigi is a warrior with a heart of gold!

This week, Chris and Matt head to the Mushroom Kingdom by way of Brooklyn for their very first adventure with their new best friend Luigi! Chris gets the most confusing ending ever! Matt kills Luigi! It's fun for everyone!

This week, Chris and Matt welcome the extraordinarily talented Ty from the extraordinarily terrific Side Character Quest and surprise him with a read from a wild book from his childhood!

This week, Matt gets slapped in the face by an adult man, Chris gets his face poked by an adult man, and THIS IS THE CLOSEST the scores have ever been! Can Matt come from behind and win the book or will Chris run away with the dang thing?

This week, Chris teams up with a blurry buddy, Matt revisits a mysterious older woman, and this could be the very last week of this book! It's time to vote for the next read!

This week, Chris gets torn to shreds, Matt learns something deeply disappointing about these 37 diamonds, and there are only four endings left, you guys! What book should be finished next?

This week, Matt has his DESTINY told to him, Chris busts out his KNIFE, and... could it be that one of the brothers has found this book's Best Read? Sure, why not!

This week, Chris has a WILD adventure (which is to say a lot of things happen), Matt trusts his feelings and uses psychic powers (a bit sort of not really), and Chris' chillzone is destroyed by Matt YOU WON'T BELIEVE HOW ok yes you will.

This week, Matt kills the Thrombey mansion real dead and Chris ventures into uncharted territory. But don't worry! He has an ace... up his sleeeeeve.

This week, Chris powers through something extremely unpleasant, Matt gets an ending that really should have been permanent, and Dormant is watching!