Vox Podcast With Mike Erre

Why does questioning your beliefs sometimes feel like a risk? What if the fear of being punished by God for struggling with doubt or shifting perspectives isn't from God at all? Mike Erre reunites with preacher and Bible scholar Bonnie Lewis for a deep dive into the tensions we face when navigating grace, obedience, and identity in Jesus. Using stories from Scripture—like the woman with the alabaster jar and Zacchaeus—and their own vulnerable questions, they explore Jesus's radically inclusive posture and how it challenges both conservative and progressive assumptions about sin, justice, and what it means to repent. This conversation invites listeners into the beautiful but complicated reality that Jesus does more than simply include—he calls, renames, invites, and reorients. Together, they wrestle with questions of personal and communal repentance, whether God punishes us for doubt, and how Jesus's grace meets us before transformation but continually invites us into deeper maturity and freedom. Key Takeaways

A raw and honest reflection for those who feel caught between theological tribes, yearning for a deeper, more authentic faith. Mike Erre and Tim Stafford launch a new conversational series responding to what it means to feel spiritually homeless in today's polarized Christian landscape. With candid vulnerability, they explore disillusionment with both progressive and conservative church cultures, and ask: Is it possible to center on Jesus without selling out to one side? This isn't cleaned-up theology with neatly drawn boundaries—it's a space of wandering, questioning, and rebuilding. If you're exhausted by toxic church politics, doctrinal quarrels on social media, and weaponized theology, this episode offers a breath of fresh (and sometimes messy) air. Key Takeaways: • Feeling Spiritually Homeless – How social media and church rhetoric are creating deep disillusionment for believers who don't fully align with conservative or progressive categories. • Christianity Without a Tribe – Naming the middle space bet

How do we navigate a term so widely misunderstood it often creates barriers instead of bridges? Mike Erre and Tim Stafford tackle this multi-layered question with humor, honesty, and depth in a lively conversation about whether we should keep or discard the term "Christian"—and what's truly at the center of the Jesus movement. This episode opens with a heartfelt apology to a listener for accidentally spoiling a blockbuster movie (Endgame, anyone?), then dives headfirst into a candid discussion sparked by a listener letter questioning whether the cultural baggage of the word "Christian" makes it worth abandoning entirely. Along the way, Mike and Tim explore the usefulness (or futility) of labels, the profound difference between identifying as "Christian" versus "follower of Jesus," and why our language must reflect our mission when engaging others inside and outside the church. They also take on listener feedback about gatekeeping, biblical double standards, and how to face the complexity of Scripture without

Can you still call it Christianity if you don't believe Jesus physically rose from the dead? This episode of the Exile Series tackles one of the most crucial and controversial questions facing the church today: what still counts as "Christian" when key beliefs are dismantled? Mike and Tim unpack an explosive New York Times interview with Union Seminary President Serene Jones, who claims one can believe in resurrection without believing that Jesus physically rose. This kicks off a deep dive into gatekeeping, core doctrine, theological mystery, and where—if anywhere—we draw lines. They explore Paul's declaration of "first importance" in 1 Corinthians 15, the implications of a metaphorical resurrection, and the struggle to balance love, inclusion, and truth without erasing the essence of Jesus's identity and mission. Whether you're rebuilding your faith, deconstructing from harmful religious narratives, or curious about where theological boundaries should lie, this conversation offers honesty, nuance, and plenty

How can Christians seriously engage with science, sexuality, and the violence in the scriptures while remaining faithful to the authority of the Bible? In this insightful and honest conversation, Mike Erre is joined by Old Testament scholar Tremper Longman III to discuss the hermeneutical frameworks required to address some of Christianity's most pressing—and often divisive—topics. Drawing from his new book, Confronting Old Testament Controversies, Tremper unpacks the complexities of evolution, interpretation, LGBTQ+ inclusion, biblical violence, and how the ancient text still speaks to our modern context. This episode is both an academic and pastoral invitation to wrestle openly and faithfully with the Bible's hardest questions. Key Takeaways: • Scripture and Hermeneutics Matter Deeply – Misusing or misunderstanding the Old Testament through poor hermeneutics has led to destructive interpretations, from colonialism to political idolatry. • Why the Old Testament Still Matters – Tremper explains why dismissing

Discover how gay Christians committed to a traditional biblical sexual ethic are faithfully navigating identity, theology, celibacy, and spiritual friendship in Part 2 of the Revoice series. Mike Erre speaks with Dr. Johanna Finnegan—MIT PhD, philosopher, and follower of Jesus—whose journey of faith, sexuality, and discipleship offers a deeply personal and thought-provoking perspective. Johanna's story unfolds with raw honesty, intellectual rigor, and unwavering commitment to living a life shaped by Christ. In this powerful and deeply reflective episode, Johanna shares how she came to faith in Jesus after growing up in a largely secular household, how being gay shaped her youth and adulthood, and what it means to submit her sexuality to Christ while finding joy, meaning, and even romantic love in ways that defy simple categories. Key Takeaways: • Facing the Tension Between Faith and Sexuality – Johanna discusses discovering she was gay at a young age and how that reality collided with traditional Christian te

Why the modern megachurch model is failing—and what should rise in its place. Mike Erre and Tim Stafford tackle one of their most candid, raw conversations yet around the toxicity of platform-centric Christianity, the pitfalls of megachurch culture, and the tension between organizational leadership and spiritual shepherding. Drawing from personal experience, listener questions, and real-world examples, they explore the deep systemic issues that plague celebrity-driven church models, while proposing a more biblical and communal way forward. They also introduce Malaika Sisay, a third-year student at The Ohio State University, whose powerful story of growing up at the intersection of a Muslim household, a white evangelical school, and a Black Pentecostal church sheds new light on how we must reimagine diversity and inclusion in Christian spaces. Key Takeaways: • The Megachurch Crisis – Why celebrity pastors, organizational culture, and brand obsession are hurting the church's mission and credibility. • Leadershi

How salvation was understood by Jesus and his first-century audience is a far cry from the transactional, "pray the prayer" model often found in modern Christianity. In a passionate and wide-ranging mailbag episode, Mike Erre explores questions around what it means to be saved, the cultural and psychological dynamics of shame (particularly in the context of abortion), and how to remain present and faithful in Christian community when we profoundly disagree—especially on issues like LGBTQ inclusion. This episode offers a deep reexamination of salvation through a biblical lens shaped by the Exodus narrative and New Testament examples, revealing a holistic, relational vision that contrasts sharply with many contemporary church models. Mike also responds to real listener questions about controversial church practices like tithing mandates for staff and offers practical wisdom for navigating Christian spaces with empathy, humility, and discernment. Key Takeaways: • Rethinking Shame and the Gospel – Clinical insigh

How do we rebuild faith after church hurt, betrayal, and deconstruction? Sophie Cherry joins Mike Erre for a powerful and timely conversation about navigating spiritual trauma, gender roles in the church, and finding a renewed passion for Jesus that survives the brokenness of Christian institutions. Drawing from her own story of being raised a pastor's kid, burned by ministry, and rediscovering the gospel, Sophie offers a fresh, compassionate perspective for those grappling with disillusionment. Together, Mike and Sophie dive into what it looks like to love Jesus while wrestling with the harm his followers sometimes cause, including powerful insights on cultural apologetics, deconversion trends, and the role of women in the modern church. They also take on listener questions related to faith in the workplace, gender dynamics, sexuality, and whether Leviticus really still matters. Key Takeaways: • Restoring Faith After Church Hurt – Sophie recounts her painful experience of being ostracized by a ministry commu

How do we love the church in her brokenness while faithfully engaging with the complex realities of faith, sexuality, and gender? That's the central question raised in this candid and courageous edition of Vox in the Raw. Mike Erre is joined by theologian and author Preston Sprinkle, director of the Center for Faith, Sexuality, and Gender, for a brutally honest conversation that embodies both truth and grace. They explore how theology and pastoral care intersect when it comes to LGBTQ+ inclusion, the ways the church has fallen short, and how followers of Jesus can engage with clarity, humility, and compassion. If you've ever wrestled with the church's treatment of LGBTQ+ individuals, been confused by the affirming vs. non-affirming divide, or wondered how to hold to biblical conviction while making space for real people and relationships—this episode is for you. Key Takeaways: • A Third Way Beyond the Binary – Preston shares how his ministry avoids extremes by upholding a traditional biblical theology of marr

How the Christian imagination can be restored in a disenchanted world, and why helping others see Christianity as desirable—not just true—is crucial to spiritual renewal. Mike Erre is joined by long-time friend and philosopher Dr. Paul Gould to unpack core themes from Paul's new book, Cultural Apologetics. Through laughter, inside jokes, and deep reflection, they explore how recovering an enchanted view of the world can help both believers and skeptics rediscover the beauty, truth, and goodness of Jesus. Key Takeaways: • What Is Cultural Apologetics? – Understanding how evangelism has shifted from rational defense of Christianity to restoring the sense that the faith is good, beautiful, and desirable—not just true. • The Crisis of Disenchantment – Exploring how our modern, secular culture has silenced transcendence and suppressed deep spiritual longings, even inside the church. • God and the Human Imagination – Why wonder, art, music, literature, and even stories like Harry Potter or Star Wars can awaken our

Deepening our collective understanding of how Christ calls his followers to navigate complex ethical and pastoral questions, this Voxology mailbag episode takes on listener questions around abortion, trauma, shame, and biblical interpretation. Mike Erre reflects thoughtfully on difficult circumstances—like when life-threatening pregnancies or birth defects are involved—and compassionately addresses real-life dilemmas that listeners are wrestling with across theological and relational lines. With honesty and humility, Mike explores how the church can hold space for grace and truth without shaming, how biblical passages like Numbers 5 have been misunderstood in the abortion debate, and how Jesus invites us to lead with empathy rather than moral certainty, especially toward those facing agonizing decisions. This episode is grounded in the Imago Dei and the call to love well, even amidst deep disagreement. Key Takeaways: • Abortion and Nuance – Why one-size-fits-all moral arguments often fall short, especially in

A deeply vulnerable and vital conversation between Mike Erre and theologian and Bible translator Bonnie Lewis around abortion, loss, and what it means to truly be pro-life. This episode goes far beyond politics, diving into Bonnie's personal story of stillbirth, grief, and theological reflection. Together, Mike and Bonnie challenge simplistic narratives and offer a broader, more compassionate lens on abortion—one rooted in a gospel that centers dignity, healing, and community over condemnation. Key Takeaways: • Abortion is Not Just a Political Issue – Reframing our understanding by centering the stories of women and the complexity of their experiences. • The Power of Maternal Instinct – How Bonnie's experience affirmed the critical importance of listening to women's deeply intuitive connection with their bodies and unborn children. • Pro-Life Is Pro-Woman – A call to expand the pro-life conversation to include emotional, mental, and spiritual care for mothers at all stages—before, during, and after pregnancy.

How the ancient Greco-Roman worldview around deformity, ability, and perceived human "worth" continues to influence our modern ethics on abortion, disability, and human dignity. Mike Erre returns to the cultural and spiritual roots of the abortion debate, drawing deeply from early Christian history, Hellenistic philosophy, and his own experience as the father of a child with Down syndrome. This episode (Part 2 of the abortion conversation) explores how early Christians responded to practices like infanticide and exposure—not with protest, but with sacrificial love—and what that could mean for Christians in today's world. Key Takeaways: • Hellenism Then and Now – How the ancient Greek worldview placed human perfection and reason at the center of worth, and how that ethos lives on today in modern humanism and cultural values. • Exposure and Infanticide in the Roman World – Examining the brutal treatment of infants deemed "unfit" or "imperfect," especially those with disabilities or born female, and the philosop

How the Imago Dei—humanity made in God's image—shapes a consistent, compassionate, and Christ-centered approach to the complex issue of abortion. In this special two-part reflection, Mike Erre opens up about profoundly personal experiences surrounding abortion, pregnancy, and his son with Down syndrome as he responds to a listener's heartfelt question: "What is your view of abortion, and what advice would you give someone struggling with that decision?" Avoiding oversimplified policies or blanket moral statements, Mike calls for a relational and deeply human approach rooted in the radical love and life-affirming orientation of the kingdom of God. Key Takeaways: • A Relational Approach Over Policy Statements – Why nuanced, personal conversations about abortion matter more than sweeping declarations or political stances. • Embodying a Consistent Pro-Life Ethic – Mike critiques inconsistencies in the modern pro-life movement while advocating for a view that includes the unborn, the vulnerable, the poor, immigran

What if the secret to real freedom isn't self-indulgence but self-control? In the kickoff episode of our new Discipline Series, Mike Erre sits down with author and editor Drew Dyck to unpack the biblical and neurological foundations of self-discipline—and how it's far more about surrender than striving. They dive deep into Drew's book, "Your Future Self Will Thank You," and explore how self-control seen through the lens of scripture is the path to true flourishing, not restriction. This is not just a discussion about breaking bad habits—this is a reimagining of how spiritual maturity, neuroscience, and Christian identity intersect. Whether you're trying to kick a scroll addiction, start reading your Bible regularly, or simply understand why "letting go and letting God" isn't the whole picture, this conversation brings meaningful insights and practical next steps. Key Takeaways: • Self-Control as Surrender – Biblical self-control isn't just about willpower, it's about putting God and others ahead of self. • Wi

How reimagining Scripture through a new translation and untangling toxic masculinity can help Christians rediscover Jesus and better live out the mission of the gospel today. Author and theologian Bonnie Lewis joins Mike to share the heart behind her groundbreaking Bible translation project "Tim Shell." They dig into the challenges she's faced as a woman translating Scripture, how Tim Shell offers new pathways for healing spiritual trauma, and why understanding both the cultural and spiritual context of Scripture matters deeply. The episode also turns to a powerful, honest conversation around toxic masculinity—including how men can course-correct toxic behavior, what biblical masculinity looks like through the life of Jesus, and how the church can be part of the solution rather than the problem. Key Takeaways: • How Bonnie Lewis's personal grief and deconstruction journey led to the "Tim Shell" Bible translation project • Why accessibility and spiritual authenticity matter more than literalism in Scripture en

What do we do when God doesn't answer our most desperate prayers? In this deeply vulnerable and honest Q&A episode, Mike Erre responds to a gut-wrenching listener question about the nature of prayer, suffering, and whether God actually intervenes the way we hope he does. This episode journeys into the pain of unanswered prayer, the theological confusion surrounding it, and how to remain faithful and hope-filled in the midst of heartbreak. Drawing from personal experience as a parent of a child with Down syndrome, Mike dives into the mystery of why suffering exists and challenges common Christian clichés that often do more harm than good. Listeners will find comfort, theological nuance, and practical wisdom as Mike affirms God's goodness in a broken world and explores how prayer is less about outcomes and more about relationship and trust. Key Takeaways: • Why "God wants us to suffer" is a harmful and theologically unsound explanation for unanswered prayer. • Viewing birth defects and tragedy as consequenc

Unpacking one of the most debated theological doctrines in church history, Mike Erre flies solo on this episode to dive deep into the Bible's use of "election" and "predestination" language. Drawing from theologians like N.T. Wright, Tim Gombis, and Scott McKnight, he outlines five key observations that debunk the idea of God arbitrarily choosing individuals for heaven or hell. Instead, Mike reframes election as a communal, missional, and deeply affectionate act from God—a calling to serve rather than a stamp of superiority. Listeners looking to make sense of scriptural predestination and how it intersects with mission, grace, and the nature of God's people will discover a thoughtful, accessible, and pastoral perspective that avoids divisiveness while remaining grounded in biblical scholarship. Key Takeaways: • God's Election Language Reflects Love, Not Exclusion – Election in the Bible is used to describe God's deep affection for His people, not to condemn others. • Predestination Is Missional, Not Privilege

Start the year with a fresh challenge to rethink why following Jesus necessitates being rooted in community and not just spiritual consumption. In this Q&A-style episode, Mike Erre and Kevin (number two!) dive into some weighty questions from listeners — questions about sexuality and gender, Christians in the military, being "just a guy in the seat," church leadership, and how to discern theological conviction from opinion. Along the way, they explore the role of church in modern Christian life, what constitutes true unity, and how to lovingly wrestle with differing beliefs inside the body of Christ. This episode is rich with pastoral wisdom, theological nuance, and some classic Mike and Kevin banter (plus, Mike's seasonal affective light lamp makes an appearance). Whether you're a church leader, churchgoer, or questioning your place in the church altogether, you'll find encouragement and challenge in equal measure. Key Takeaways: • You Can't Follow Jesus Alone – Practicing the way of Jesus requires deep