Nefarious New York Podcast

This is an episode about domestic and child abuse. Joel Steinberg and Hedda Nussbaum illegally adopted Lisa and Mitchell. Things went horribly wrong.

George Weber found someone to fulfill his smothering fetish on Craigslist. The encounter ended with George being stabbed 50 times.

A beloved local taxi driver is murdered in his car. The police think robbery but the real story goes much deeper.

A son wakes up to find that his parents have been beaten and murdered. Did the son murder his parents or was it someone else?

Lisette was a doting mother of 2 beautiful children. Did jealousy or postpartum psychosis make her kill her children?

Simeonette Mapes Crupi was found by her husband. She was murdered and at first glance it looked like a burglary gone wrong. 

Audrey Herron disappeared on a rainy night in 2002. Her case is unsolved.

Seven children and their father died in a house fire in Cohoes, New York. The only survivor was the wife and mother. 

In this episode we cover Peter Muhlbach, a teacher at Long Island City High School. We also cover Irwin Goldberg, a teacher and dean at Stevenson High School.

A young entrepreneur is murdered and dismembered. 

The Worst Woman on Earth. This episode takes us way back and we absolutely have more laughs than usual. If that will be offensive to you maybe this isn't the episode for you. We support all mental health issues and our finding some humor in this is in no way meant to offend anyone in anyway at all. 

Bonnie and Richard met and fell in love at Yale. When Bonnie wanted to break things off Richard did the unthinkable. 

Michelle Walker was 14 when she was assaulted and murdered, Patricia England was 19, and Lisa Gibbens was 25. Their cases went unsolved for over 15 years. Finally, DNA brought their killer to justice.

A young, beautiful, vibrant nursing student at Binghamton University is murdered. The case takes us from Upstate New York to Nicaragua. 

This is the conclusion. The men get exonerated but are they linked to other cases? Did the police have the right guys or did science clear them without question?

This is a case about a young girl that went missing and later turned up dead. Were her killers caught or were they wrongly convicted? The deeper you look into the connections the less sure you are. 

Trigger Warning. This is a story of incest and abuse and how the victim escaped her abuser.

Peter and Joan Porco were brutally attacked by an intruder with an axe. Could it have been one of their own children?

Michelle Lee was an up and coming forensic scientist in the NYPD. Her boyfriend Gary MCGurk is the prime suspect in her gruesome death. Her diary proves to be a valuable piece of evidence.